Back when Murder Mystery 1 still had a shop, this vintage gun sold for 25 Cash during a short July 4–6, 2014 window. That shop is long gone, so the only way to get one now is through trading. A collector's piece rather than a hot trade — for similar historical value, think Boneblade or Cavern (2019).
America is a Vintage gun in Murder Mystery 2. Its combined value is 7.5, #4 of 10 vintage items and #367 of 921 valued items overall. Demand is very low: it sits in inventories for a while, and buyers often ask for a discount.
Closest in value: Boneblade (7.5), Cavern (2019) (7.5), Eternal II (7.5). Use them as a benchmark for a fair one-for-one trade.
Value history
What it is worth in other items
How many of each item equal one America by value. Demand differs between items, so check it before you trade.